Solar quote comparison

How to compare two solar installation quotes

A larger solar array can earn more each year and still take longer to pay for itself. Work through two offers for a Berlin roof to see what the extra panels buy.

Rows of dark solar panels on a terracotta roof in a Berlin neighborhood

Try the two Berlin quotes

Gather the figures for your own roof

Start with the annual output you expect on your roof, what a kWh costs on your electricity bill and what your utility pays or credits for an exported kWh. Choose the currency on your quotes and enter both offers in that currency. If the utility quotes electricity in a smaller unit, convert it to the main currency unit first. In the Berlin example, 32 euro cents per kWh becomes 0.32 in the EUR field.

Get both offers onto one page

Ask each installer for the total price you would pay, panel capacity in kilowatt-peak (kWp), expected annual output in kilowatt-hours (kWh) and an itemized scope. Check scaffolding, electrical work, commissioning and recurring service charges. If one price includes a battery, ask for the panel-only price and a production estimate for that configuration. The Berlin example uses two cash purchases with no battery or grant. All prices, rates and yields in it are illustrative.

Check how much energy each roof layout can produce

Divide the installer’s annual kWh estimate by the quoted kWp to get specific yield. For Quote A, 3,800 kWh divided by 4 kWp gives 950 kWh per kWp per year. Suppose Quote B uses the same roof plane and yield. Its 6 kWp would produce 5,700 kWh. If the extra panels go on a shaded or differently oriented roof face, ask for that layout’s production estimate before accepting the same yield for both.

Use the location estimate as a cross-check

If a quote omits expected output, the calculator can look up local sunlight through NASA POWER. NASA estimates how much sunlight reaches a surface held at its optimum year-round tilt for that location. The calculator applies an assumed 80% performance ratio to convert that sunlight into an approximate electrical yield. An east-facing roof or a nearby chimney may change actual generation. Enter 950 manually to reproduce the two offers here, or use a roof-specific figure from the installer.

Put a price on household use and exports

The Berlin household assumes it can use 60% of A’s output directly, or 2,280 kWh. The remaining 1,520 kWh would go to the grid. At an assumed purchase price of €0.32 per kWh and export rate of €0.08 per kWh, A avoids €729.60 of electricity purchases and earns €121.60 from exports. Use the variable price per kWh from your bill. A fixed monthly charge that you will keep paying brings no saving. Check your local export agreement for the rates and credit limits that apply to each offer.

Calculate each quote’s simple payback

A costs €7,800. Subtract its €90 annual maintenance allowance from €851.20 of annual energy value to get €761.20. Dividing €7,800 by €761.20 gives about 10.2 years to recover the outlay. For B, assume the household uses 45% of the larger output. That is 2,565 kWh used and 3,135 kWh exported. B produces €1,071.60 of annual value, or €951.60 after €120 maintenance. Its €10,200 cost takes about 10.7 years to recover at that rate. These estimates hold the annual cash flows constant.

Ask when the extra €2,400 pays back

Someone choosing between the two offers faces a second question. B costs €2,400 more up front and delivers €190.40 more per year after maintenance. Divide the extra price by the extra annual benefit to get about 12.6 years of incremental payback. After ten years B would have earned €1,904 extra, leaving €496 of its premium to recover. If the higher-priced offer produces the same or a lower annual benefit, those cash flows never recover its premium.

Ask the installer to defend the assumption that changes the decision

Most of B’s extra generation goes to the grid in this example. Ask to see how the installer matched a typical day’s production to your household’s consumption. A heat pump used mainly in winter or a car parked away from home during daylight can change that match. Try a lower self-consumption share in the calculator and compare the premium payback with the time you expect to own the system. For a financed offer, separately compare the payment schedule, interest and any scheduled equipment replacements.

Two illustrative panel-only offers for the same Berlin household
MeasureQuote AQuote B
Installed cost and capacity€7,800 for 4 kWp€10,200 for 6 kWp
Annual generation3,800 kWh5,700 kWh
Used at home / exported2,280 / 1,520 kWh2,565 / 3,135 kWh
Annual energy value less maintenance€851.20 − €90 = €761.20€1,071.60 − €120 = €951.60
Simple payback10.2 years10.7 years

References