Courier Upgrade ROI Calculator

Compare delivery failure rates and the cost of a courier upgrade. Estimate the change in order profit and see how many additional parcels must reach customers to cover the premium.

Free to use · No account needed

Your numbers

Edit the example amounts to get your result.

Count every eligible dispatch, including unsuccessful deliveries.
Share of dispatched parcels that finish the delivery cycle undelivered. (%)
Use trial results or enter a rate you want to test. (%)
Revenue retained after product cost, selling fees and standard delivery.
Enter unrecovered costs as a positive amount, after any refunds or credits.
Extra cost above your standard courier fee for each eligible parcel.

Enter all amounts in the same currency.

How it works

Extra successful deliveries = dispatches × (current failure % − upgraded failure %) ÷ 100. Profit change = extra successful deliveries × (contribution on success + loss avoided on failure) − total upgrade fees.

Worked example

A German shop sends 500 parcels. It earns €18 on a completed delivery and loses €12 on an undelivered parcel. Reducing failures from 20% to 14% means 30 additional deliveries worth €900. At €1.20 per dispatch, the upgrade costs €600, leaves €300 extra contribution and returns 50% on the premium. It needs 20 additional deliveries to break even.

Start with parcels that have completed their delivery cycle. A parcel that arrives on the second attempt counts as a success if the customer keeps the order. Use the same definition when estimating the upgraded service’s rate.

A recovered delivery changes two sides of the comparison. The shop avoids the failed parcel’s loss and earns the completed sale’s contribution. Charge the premium across all the parcels sent through the upgraded service.

Measure the routes the new courier would serve

If you would upgrade only large parcels or one postcode area, use the failure rate for those dispatches. Give both groups enough time for a second attempt, collection or return to sender. For a small trial, keep the counts alongside the rates. Six failures among 30 shipments and 60 among 300 both give 20%, but one parcel changes the first rate much more. Recalculate with one or two more failures in the trial group to see whether the decision changes.

Build the two delivery outcomes from your records

For a completed order, start with the money you kept and deduct the product cost, standard outbound charge and selling fees. For a failed order, add the costs you actually lost, such as non-refundable carriage, return handling or damage. A returned item that goes back on the shelf can retain its value. Include only its unrecoverable loss. Keep the courier’s quoted upgrade fee out of both figures because the calculator charges it once on each dispatch.

Frequently asked questions

The failure rate fell from 20% to 14%. Which number should I enter?
Enter 20 for the current service and 14 for the upgraded service. The difference is six percentage points, equal to six more successful deliveries per 100 dispatches. Putting 30 in the second box would describe a service with a 30% failure rate.
What if the courier upgrades only some orders?
Enter the number of parcels that qualify and use delivery rates and average costs for that group. If heavy parcels have different margins or surcharges, run them separately and add the two groups’ estimated profit changes.

Read a worked guide