Growth calculations

How to compare growth with CAGR over different periods

Compare two start-to-end outcomes using the compound annual growth rate. Check when deposits, withdrawals and other cash flows call for a different calculation.

Calculator, notebook and paperwork on a desk

Start with two comparable values for each example

Consider two hypothetical accounts in the same currency with no external deposits or withdrawals. Account A grows from $5,000 to $7,200 over four years. Account B grows from $5,000 to $6,500 over two years. Use the same approach to fees for both figures. Balances measured after fees already reflect those fees, so subtracting them again would understate growth.

Convert the overall gain to a yearly compound rate

Divide the ending value by the starting value. Raise that ratio to the power of one divided by the number of years, then subtract one and multiply by 100. For A, the multiplier is 7,200 ÷ 5,000 = 1.44. Its fourth root is about 1.09545, giving a CAGR of 9.54%. For B, the square root of 1.30 is about 1.14018, giving 14.02%. Enter each set of figures separately in the CAGR Calculator.

Read the yearly rate alongside the total gain

Account A gained $2,200, or 44%, over four years. Account B gained $1,500, or 30%, over two years. The annualized rate ranks B higher across its own period, while A gained more dollars over its longer period. The calculation smooths the path between the two values. It leaves individual ups and downs and conditions in the two periods out of the comparison.

Check for money added or taken out

Suppose a balance starts at $5,000, ends a year later at $6,300 and includes a $1,000 deposit just before the closing valuation. The simple endpoint calculation reports 26% growth in the balance. Only $300 of the $1,300 increase remains after removing the deposit. When the timing of payments matters, list the actual dates and amounts. A dated cash-flow calculation such as XIRR uses the starting payment, deposits, withdrawals or payouts, and ending value.

Make the measurement period explicit

Record the start date, end date, values and years so someone can reproduce the calculation. Use a fractional number of years for a partial year. For a history with annual balances and no external flows, keep those balances beside the CAGR result to show how much the path varied. When comparing equivalent periods is possible, use the same start and end dates, or put the different periods clearly beside their rates.

Two hypothetical accounts with different holding periods
MeasureAccount AAccount B
Years42
Total gain44%30%
CAGR9.54%14.02%

References